The Milburn Review has been published today in an effort to increase in the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEETs). Among its aims the review targets an extra 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities to be created through employer incentives, and an extra 150,000 18- to 24-year-olds studying further education courses at colleges and other training providers each year.
The government estimate that nearly one million young people aged 16 to 24 in the UK are not in education, employment or training. As such, author of the report, former minister Alan Milburn has stated that the system needs a “complete reset”, if those individuals are to encouraged into work or education.
The review’s central finding is that youth disengagement is not simply caused by a lack of motivation, but by failures across education, healthcare, welfare and the employment system.
Alan Milburn has given a year of his life to this review and worked tirelessly to deliver it. Make UK will do everything we can, alongside government and business, to turn these recommendations into reality.
Stephen Phipson CBE, CEO, Make UK
The review identifies several contributing factors, including poor mental health, limited access to apprenticeships, fewer entry-level jobs, socioeconomic inequality and inadequate support when transitioning from education into employment.
Its recommendations also call for greater alignment between education, industry and every level of government in order to give young people more visibility of future career options and greater access to skills, training and experience.
Commenting on the review’s findings, Stephen Phipson CBE, CEO of Make UK, said: “We have been involved in this review from the outset and, if implemented, its recommendations could prove truly ground-breaking. Alan Milburn understands that young people want the opportunity to build skilled and rewarding careers, but too many struggle to get that first step. Cutting employer NICs for young people, alongside a stronger focus on work readiness and technical education, are practical measures that can make a real difference.
“Manufacturers want to create jobs, apprenticeships and training opportunities, but they are doing so against significant cost pressures from energy, employment and taxation. We cannot expect business to help tackle youth inactivity while simultaneously making it more expensive to employ and train the next generation.
“Alan Milburn has given a year of his life to this review and worked tirelessly to deliver it. Make UK will do everything we can, alongside government and business, to turn these recommendations into reality.”
However, a leading skills charity has claimed that the review may lack the power to deliver its true ambition. While welcoming the direction and purpose of the review, Enginuity, which works with SMEs across engineering and manufacturing, sets out the hurdles that need to be overcome for it to be effective.
While the charity has welcomed the review’s recognition that employers need support to create opportunities, but it warns that young people could miss out on technical careers unless that support addresses the sector’s recruitment and training challenges.
Ann Watson MBE, CEO of Enginuity, said: “Alan Milburn rightly says that government cannot ask business to create more first opportunities while ignoring the effect its own decisions have on whether those opportunities are viable.
“This report risks not going further, faster – and that failure lands on the very young people it promises to help.
“There is much in this review that recognises the pressures employers face. But for engineering and manufacturing, some of the measures businesses need most are either missing or risk arriving too slowly.
“The review rightly recognises that employers cannot create these opportunities alone. But it does not go far enough in addressing the practical barriers facing engineering and manufacturing SMEs from the viability of specialist apprenticeship provision to the cost and capacity involved in taking on and supporting a young person.
“You can promise 100% funding for an under-25 apprenticeship, but if the funding band makes a specialist engineering standard uneconomic for a training provider to deliver, that opportunity simply won’t exist.”
Enginuity’s Mind the Gap report, issued earlier this year, estimated that £5.2bn was being lost to the economy every year due to the lack of available skills in the engineering and manufacturing sector. Currently, there are more than 40,000 job vacancies in the sector, which covers much of the key focal points in the government’s Industrial Strategy.
The challenge is to connect the review’s youth ambition with the sectors and occupations where skills are already in short supply.
There is much in this review that recognises the pressures employers face. But for engineering and manufacturing, some of the measures businesses need most are either missing or risk arriving too slowly.
Ann Watson MBE, CEO, Enginuity
The proposed National Insurance relief could help smaller employers recruit young people. But if engineering and manufacturing are excluded from the first wave, businesses in these strategically important sectors risk having to wait for support they need now.
The review must also be matched by a review of apprenticeship funding bands so that specialist engineering training is viable to deliver.
Ann Watson MBE went on to add: “Alan Milburn recognises that employers cannot create these opportunities alone. But it does not go far enough in addressing the practical barriers facing engineering and manufacturing SMEs from the viability of specialist apprenticeship provision to the cost and capacity involved in taking on and supporting a young person.”
The review, published today, includes an “opportunity guarantee”: a legal duty to offer every under-25 an apprenticeship, college place, job coaching or a job, with benefits cut for those who refuse.
Almost a million 16–24-year-olds are NEET (Not in Education, Employment or Training), and the state currently spends £22bn a year on economically inactive young people.
“Engineering and manufacturing businesses want to offer young people work, but smaller employers need support to make those opportunities viable,” said Ann.
“Skills are pointless without jobs at the end of them. Engineering and manufacturing should be included from the outset in targeted NI relief, alongside action on specialist training and the practical burden of taking on a young person.”
Enginuity said the review’s wider ambitions are welcome, but support for young people and the employers who will provide their opportunities must move together.
“A youth guarantee is only meaningful if there is an employer at the other end able to provide the opportunity,” Watson added. “The ambition is right. The test now is whether government makes recruitment and training viable for the businesses needed to deliver it.”
Among the measures that Enginuity is calling for:
- Put SMEs at the centre of delivery, with clear routes for employers to engage with employment advisers, colleges and training providers.
- Make technical training viable and accessible, including reviewing funding for niche apprenticeship standards and where small cohorts put provision at risk.
- Reduce the practical burden of taking on young people, including exploring shared apprenticeship models and support for mentoring, supervision and administration.
- Invest in early intervention and inclusive pathways, helping young people discover technical careers before they become disconnected from education.
- Protect adult and higher-level skills alongside youth opportunities, including considering a Skills Tax Credit to encourage employer investment in workforce development.
Hilary Leevers, Chief Executive, EngineeringUK added: “The Milburn Review recognises that too many young people face barriers as they move from education into employment. We welcome its focus on ensuring that all young people experience a broad and relevant education, combining strong academic foundations with opportunities for practical learning, enrichment, meaningful employer engagement and technical study.
“The engineering and technology sector provides fulfilling, well-paid careers at all levels across the UK. And the UK needs more engineers, technicians and technologists to drive innovation, grow the economy and tackle society’s biggest challenges. To meet that need, we must ensure that every young person can access high-quality pathways into engineering and technology, whatever their background.
“EngineeringUK has worked closely with government and partners across education and industry to help make pathways into engineering and technology more inclusive and accessible. Through our programmes, we connect schools, employers, engineers, technicians and role models with young people, helping them understand the wide range of rewarding careers available and the routes into them.
“We particularly welcome the recommendation to refocus apprenticeship funding on young people under 25. EngineeringUK has long highlighted the concerning decline in under-25 starts in engineering and technology apprenticeships and has consistently called for action to reverse this trend. Alongside greater support for employers, this recommendation could help create more high-quality opportunities for young people to gain the skills, experience and qualifications that employers need.
“The review provides an important opportunity to strengthen connections between education and employment. We urge government to seize that opportunity and build on Alan Milburn’s recommendations. Government must now look to create a system that works for young people, employers and the wider economy. We look forward to supporting that work.”
James Partington, Director of Policy and Impact at the Institution of Mechanical Engineers (IMechE) said: “The IMechE welcomes Alan Milburn’s proposals to tackle youth unemployment and help more young people move from benefits into work. Engineers and engineering businesses already play an important role in tackling youth inactivity, helping young people understand what engineering offers and the academic and vocational routes into the profession, while providing practical opportunities through apprenticeships, industry placements and work-based learning.
“Success will depend on creating the right conditions for employers to play their part. With rising employment costs placing pressure on businesses, employers need the confidence and financial capacity to continue investing in training and meaningful opportunities for young people.
“This must also go hand in hand with supporting the existing workforce. As innovation reshapes industry, retaining, retraining and upskilling experienced workers is vital to productivity and ensuring they can pass their knowledge on to the next generation.”
Commenting on the launch of the review, Yselkla Farmer, CEO, Industry trade body, BEAMA added: “Lower employer National Insurance for young workers should go where the jobs are. Britain’s electricity networks need 71,000 people over the next decade, and young people are particularly under-represented in the manufacturing side of the sector. We’d like to see government include those manufacturers in the first phase, alongside retail and hospitality. It could be a real step towards getting more young people into skilled work.”
“Doubling the number of young apprentices is good news for our sector. The sticking point will be the college courses that lead into apprenticeships. Right now, they aren’t always available or easy to get onto. We’d like to see government make those courses easier to access, so more young people can start an apprenticeship.
“Investing in Britain’s electricity grid could give thousands of young people who are out of work a stable, skilled career. 15,400 of the jobs the sector needs to fill by 2035 won’t need advanced academic qualifications. With the right training and support, young people not in education, employment or training could step into them. That would transform a workforce where only 7% of people are under 25, compared with 11% across the UK workforce.
“Too few young people know that careers in the electricity networks sector exist, let alone how to get into them. That’s why we are creating a single front door, independent and funded by the sector itself. Our Sector Platform will show young people the jobs on offer and how they can progress, from their first role to skilled trades like substation technicians and commissioning engineers. Milburn’s measures should plug straight into it.”
Dr Rhys Morgan, Senior Principal Consultant, Education and Skills, Royal Academy of Engineering, said: “Engineering businesses have an important role in providing meaningful training and employment for many thousands of young people when government ambitions for economic growth and infrastructure renewal require many more engineers and technicians. Engineering contributes over a third of the UK’s total economic output and supports around 8.5 million jobs and is unique among professions in providing access to young people straight from school with routes to learning the skills that lead professional careers.
“SMEs make up over 90% of engineering businesses and we know they can find it particularly difficult to navigate the complexity of the system of qualifications, progression routes from school to employment, financial support and other administrative requirements and this is preventing them offering opportunities they know young people want. We particularly welcome the report’s acknowledgement of the difficulties SMEs face and suggestions for ways to reduce their burden and the barriers that prevent them increasing opportunities for young people and reducing the numbers not in education, employment or training.”
For more articles like this, visit our People & Skills channel



